I have always admired the 18XX games from afar, but when GMT announced they were producing one – designed by Tom Lehmann – , I knew it was a sign. I picked my copy of 1846 up from a USA dealer as part of a bulk order filling in some gaps in my Lord of the Rings LCG, and it duly arrived a couple of weeks ago. It’s taken this long for me to get it out of the wrapper, check the contents, and have a first look of the rulebook.
The physical components look to be fine, with a dandy mounted game board. The rules however left me with something of a sore head. It appeared to me that the rules assumed players were familiar with 18XX games, and a lot – or some – prior knowledge was expected. In fairness, after spending some more time on a closer read of the rules, I am reasonably satisfied all the information is there, just well hidden. And the example of play was a life saver.
Since the playing time is on the very wrong side of 3 hours, I doubt this will surface at my regular (euro) gaming session, but I am determined to assemble a crew of volunteers to try it out.